Что даёт аудит

Это отчёт по небольшому API заказов. Каждая находка называет файл и строку, цитирует код, объясняет, что получает атакующий, и заканчивается патчем и способом проверки.

Написан вручную для этой страницы: репозиторий вымышленный, модель не вызывалась. Ваши отчёты пишутся на языке, на котором вы пользуетесь сайтом.

acme/checkout-api

Сводка

The service exposes an order API backed by Postgres and a Stripe webhook. Two issues are exploitable by an unauthenticated or lightly authenticated caller: a SQL query built by string concatenation in the order lookup, and an order endpoint that trusts the identifier in the URL without checking who owns it. A Stripe secret is committed in `src/config/env.ts`, which makes rotation the first task regardless of the rest. Session handling and the webhook signature check are sound.

Оценка риска
82
Находки
4
  1. 01КритическийSQL injection in the order lookupCWE-89

    src/routes/orders.ts:42–46 · уверенность: high · fable + codex

    `GET /orders/:id` builds its query by concatenating the `id` path parameter into SQL. The parameter is taken straight from the URL and never validated, so any caller controls the statement that runs.

    const { rows } = await db.query(
      "select * from orders where id = " + req.params.id,
    );

    Последствия

    Full read of the orders table, including customer names, addresses and payment references, and a plausible path to writing or dropping data.

    Сценарий эксплуатации

    A request to `/orders/1 or 1=1` returns every order in the table. `/orders/1; drop table orders --` runs a second statement on a driver that allows it. No account is needed: the route is reachable before the session check on line 39.

    Исправление

    Pass the identifier as a bound parameter and reject anything that is not a UUID before the query runs.

    Как исправить

    1. Validate the parameter: `if (!isUuid(req.params.id)) return res.status(400).json({ error: "Invalid order id." });`
    2. Replace the concatenated query with a parameterized one, as in the patch below.
    3. Search the rest of `src/routes` for the same pattern — `db.query("… " +` — and convert those too.
    4. Add a regression test that requests `/orders/1 or 1=1` and expects 400.

    Патч

    const { rows } = await db.query(
      "select * from orders where id = $1",
      [req.params.id],
    );

    Как проверить

    Replay `GET /orders/1%20or%201=1`: it must answer 400, and the Postgres log must show the parameterized statement with the raw value bound, not interpolated.

  2. 02ВысокийAny signed-in user can read any orderCWE-639

    src/routes/orders.ts:39–41 · уверенность: high

    The handler checks that a session exists but never compares the order's owner with the caller. The identifier in the URL is the only thing that decides which record is returned.

    if (!req.session?.userId) return res.status(401).end();
    // … no ownership check before the query below

    Последствия

    Cross-customer data exposure: addresses, totals and payment references belonging to other accounts.

    Сценарий эксплуатации

    A customer who signs up legitimately can iterate order identifiers and read other customers' orders. Nothing in the logs distinguishes this from normal use.

    Исправление

    Scope the query to the session's user, so an identifier alone is never enough.

    Как исправить

    1. Add `and user_id = $2` to the query and pass `req.session.userId`.
    2. Return 404 rather than 403 when the row is missing, so the endpoint does not confirm which identifiers exist.
    3. Apply the same scoping to `PATCH /orders/:id` and `POST /orders/:id/refund`.

    Патч

    const { rows } = await db.query(
      "select * from orders where id = $1 and user_id = $2",
      [req.params.id, req.session.userId],
    );
    if (rows.length === 0) return res.status(404).end();

    Как проверить

    Sign in as one account and request an order created by another: the response must be 404, and the row must not appear in the body.

  3. 03ВысокийStripe secret key committed to the repositoryCWE-798

    src/config/env.ts:12 · уверенность: high · fable + codex

    A live Stripe secret key is assigned as a fallback when the environment variable is missing. Anyone with read access to the repository — or to its history — has the key.

    export const STRIPE_KEY = process.env.STRIPE_SECRET_KEY ?? "sk_live_51H…";

    Последствия

    Full API access to the payment account, independent of this service.

    Сценарий эксплуатации

    The key is in every clone and in the commit history. It allows charges, refunds and customer reads against the live account until it is rotated.

    Исправление

    Rotate the key first, then remove the fallback so a missing variable fails loudly at boot.

    Как исправить

    1. Roll the key in the Stripe dashboard now; the committed one must be treated as public.
    2. Replace the fallback with a hard failure, as in the patch.
    3. Purge the value from history (`git filter-repo`) or accept that the old key stays exposed and rely on the rotation.
    4. Add a secret scan to CI so the next one is caught before it merges.

    Патч

    const key = process.env.STRIPE_SECRET_KEY;
    if (!key) throw new Error("STRIPE_SECRET_KEY is not set");
    export const STRIPE_KEY = key;

    Как проверить

    Start the service without `STRIPE_SECRET_KEY`: it must refuse to boot instead of using a built-in value.

  4. 04СреднийNo rate limit on the refund endpointCWE-770

    src/routes/orders.ts:88 · уверенность: medium

    `POST /orders/:id/refund` performs a Stripe call per request with no limit per account or per order. The handler is also not idempotent: two requests that arrive together can both pass the `status !== "refunded"` check.

    router.post("/orders/:id/refund", requireSession, async (req, res) => {

    Последствия

    Double refunds and a bill at the payment provider for traffic nobody asked for.

    Сценарий эксплуатации

    A customer sending the same refund twice within a few milliseconds can have the order refunded twice before the status is written back.

    Исправление

    Limit the endpoint per account and make the refund idempotent at the database level.

    Как исправить

    1. Add a limiter keyed on the session's user, e.g. 5 refunds per hour.
    2. Claim the refund with a conditional update — `update orders set status = 'refunding' where id = $1 and status = 'paid' returning id` — and only call Stripe when a row comes back.
    3. Pass an idempotency key to the Stripe call so a retry cannot charge twice.

    Как проверить

    Fire two refund requests for the same order in parallel: exactly one must reach Stripe, and the second must answer 409.

Следующие шаги

  1. Rotate the committed Stripe key.
  2. Parameterize the order lookup and add the ownership check.
  3. Make refunds idempotent and rate limited.
  4. Add a secret scan and a query-building lint rule to CI.

Что сделано хорошо

  • The Stripe webhook verifies the signature against the raw request body before parsing it.
  • Session cookies are `HttpOnly`, `SameSite=Lax` and `Secure` in production.
  • Database credentials come from the environment; only the Stripe key had a committed fallback.
Проанализировано файлов: 5
  • src/routes/orders.ts
  • src/db/client.ts
  • src/lib/session.ts
  • src/config/env.ts
  • src/routes/webhooks.ts
Проверить свой репозиторийКак это работает